Sunderland or Middlesbrough? What £250 a month looks like in each
If you are buying your first rental in the North East, you have probably narrowed it to two towns and you are now comparing asking prices. Asking prices will not tell you which to buy. What a three-bedroom house actually lets for will, and the two towns answer very differently.
Here are the numbers, and then the one rule that matters.
What a three-bed actually lets for
Sunderland: £850 a month. That is a median from seventeen lets that were agreed rather than advertised.
Middlesbrough: £725 a month on the old town-wide figure. But that average is hiding something. Within the borough, three-beds in Hemlington and Coulby Newham are achieving £840, while central and north Middlesbrough — TS1 to TS4, including Berwick Hills — is achieving £678 across nineteen lets.
Same borough. £160 a month apart. That gap is worth more than any negotiation.
What that means for the price you can pay
The calculation is the same everywhere: take the rent, take off 12% for management if you use an agent, take off about £233 a month for insurance and running costs, then take off the mortgage interest. What is left is what the house pays you. My buyers need £250 left.
At today's rates, a three-bedroom house works at:
Sunderland — up to £65,231. Middlesbrough, Hemlington and Coulby Newham — up to £63,046. Middlesbrough, central and north — up to £27,960.
That last number is not a typo, and it is why so many people tell you Middlesbrough is cheap and still cannot make it work. At £678 a month the rent simply cannot carry a mortgage on a £90,000 house.
What the market is actually asking
The median three-bedroom asking price in Sunderland is £100,000. The ceiling is £65,231. So the typical house is asking half again what the rent can carry.
In Middlesbrough the median asking price is £95,000, against a central ceiling of £27,960 and a TS8 ceiling of £63,046. The typical house is asking between one and a half and three times what works, depending on the postcode.
So which would I buy?
Neither, at the asking price. But if a three-bedroom house appeared in Sunderland at £63,000 with a freehold title and an EPC you can live with, it would work — £257 a month left after costs, by the sums above. And if one appeared in Hemlington at £60,000, it would work too.
The difference between the two towns is not the rent. It is how close the stock is to the price that works. Sunderland's ceiling is within reach of what some sellers will accept. Central Middlesbrough's is not, and no amount of charm closes a £67,000 gap.
The rule to take away
Work out the ceiling for the postcode before you look at a single house. Rent the street actually achieves — not the town average, and not the asking rent — multiplied by 0.88, minus £233, minus the monthly interest on 75% of the price. If what is left is under £250, the house is too expensive, however nice it is.
And check the postcode, not the town. Middlesbrough is not one market. It is two, £160 a month apart, and the difference decides whether your first rental pays you or costs you.
Rents are let-agreed medians: Sunderland 3-bed £850 from 17 lets; Middlesbrough £725 town-wide, with TS8 at £840 from 4 lets and TS1–TS4 at £678 from 19, as reported in NGU Homes' November landlord update. Costs modelled at 12% management, £233 monthly running costs, £40 insurance, 75% loan to value, interest-only at 6.5%. Ceilings are modelled, not quoted lender products.