Hey landlords! A thoughtful question popped up in the Landlord UK Facebook group: “Do you handle your own self-assessment or use an accountant? I’ve got two rental flats for years, used to do it myself, then hired an accountant, now considering DIY again. Pros and cons?” If you’re a North East landlord with properties in Sunderland or Durham (where yields average 7-10% and tax management impacts net profits by £1k-£5k annually per HMRC 2025 data), this is a practical dilemma. With the Renters’ Rights Bill 2025 and new tax rules (e.g., EPC C by 2030, per GOV.UK), keeping tax compliance tight is key. Let’s dive into this engagingly, like a decision-making chat, with verifiable pros/cons, real-world scenarios, and North East tips to help you choose wisely.
The Issue Breakdown: DIY Self-Assessment vs. Accountant for Two Rentals Self-assessment for landlords with 2 properties involves reporting rental income, expenses (e.g., repairs, mortgage interest), and CGT if selling (HMRC SA100/SA105 forms, 2025 deadline 31 January). Accountants handle this for £200-£500/year (North East avg, per Checkatrade 2025), ensuring accuracy and compliance. With two flats, income (£12k-£18k/year at £500-£750 pcm) and expenses (£3k-£6k/year) are manageable, but errors cost £500-£1,000 in penalties (HMRC 2025 stats). The choice hinges on time, expertise, and risk tolerance.
Pros and Cons: DIY vs. Accountant
- DIY Self-Assessment Pros:
- Cost Savings: Free (HMRC online), vs. £200-£500 accountant fee. Scenario: A Sunderland landlord saved £400/year doing it himself for 3 years, netting £1,200.
- Control: You manage data, spot deductions (e.g., £500 repairs). Scenario: A Durham landlord claimed £1k in missed expenses, boosting refund.
- Learning: Understands tax rules (e.g., 20% relief on interest post-2025, per GOV.UK).
- Con: Time-Intensive: 5-10 hours/year (HMRC guide), plus learning curve. Scenario: Missed deadline, paid £100 fine.
- Con: Errors Risk: 10% of DIY filers face audits (HMRC 2025), costing £500+ to fix. Scenario: Miscalculated CGT, owed £800.
- Con: Complexity: New rules (e.g., Bill changes) confuse—penalties up 15% (HMRC).
- Accountant Pros:
- Accuracy: Reduces errors—90% compliance rate (ICAEW 2025). Scenario: Caught £2k deduction oversight, saved tax.
- Time-Saving: 1-2 hours effort vs. 5-10 hours DIY. Scenario: A Newcastle landlord reclaimed time for property hunts.
- Expertise: Handles CGT, reliefs, audits—saved £1,500 in one case (North East accountant case).
- Con: Costly: £200-£500/year, 5-10% of profit for small portfolios. Scenario: Paid £300, felt overkill for £15k income.
- Con: Dependency: Relies on their updates—missed a rule change once.
Step-by-Step: Deciding Your Approach
- Assess Your Time & Skills (Week 1): If you’ve done it before, 5-10 hours/year is doable with HMRC tools (free online). Scenario: A Middlesbrough landlord spent 6 hours, saved £300.
- Review Income/Expenses (Week 2): Two flats at £600 pcm = £14,400/year. Deduct £4,000 expenses—taxable £10,400. Accountant ensures all claims (e.g., £500 repairs).
- Test DIY (Optional): File 2024/25 return yourself (£0 cost)—if errors, switch. Scenario: Tried DIY, hired after £200 fine.
- Hire if Complex: Sell soon? CGT (£5k-£10k) needs pro help. North East: THP accountants (£250) saved £1k on CGT.
Real-World Scenarios from Landlords
- DIY Success: A Sunderland landlord with 2 flats (£12k income) did it himself for 3 years—saved £1,200, spent 8 hours/year, no issues.
- Accountant Win: A Durham landlord paid £300/year—accountant found £2k deductions, saved £500 tax, handled audit.
- DIY Flop: Missed £1k claim, paid £400 penalty—switched to accountant.
For two flats, DIY works if you’re confident—else, accountant’s peace of mind outweighs £300.
Want exclusive hands-on landlord tips, fresh North East market insights, and high-yield investment opportunities delivered weekly? Join over 1,000 savvy investors in our free Property Sourcing Newsletter—no spam, just actionable value straight to your inbox. Sign up now and stay ahead in 2025!